Two urgent care doctors in Bakersfield, California discussed their own data and questioned the wisdom of social distancing and shutdowns in their area in an interview with a local news station. Californians are under strict stay-at-home orders. Some residents have gotten tickets for watching the sunset at the beach and one man was arrested for paddle boarding alone on the ocean, while their governor Gavin Newsom commuted 21 prison sentences and pardoned five people, some of whom killed children, citing coronavirus concerns.
YouTube removed the video, citing "content that explicitly disputes the efficacy of local health authority recommended guidance on social distancing that may lead others to act against that guidance." Note that their beef wasn't that the information was false or that the doctors recommending violating the law, but that they were disputing the authorities' guidance. But as YouTuber Matt Christiansen observes, the WHO has changed its own guidelines. Are they violating terms of service for disputing the WHO? And how did they change their minds--wasn't it through pushback, not deference?
This should worry some of us who dispute dietary guidelines--the same people who own YouTube own the platform I'm on here. I backed up my blog to my computer tonight.
Watch the video, posted on 23ABC News, and decide for yourself.
YouTube removed the video, citing "content that explicitly disputes the efficacy of local health authority recommended guidance on social distancing that may lead others to act against that guidance." Note that their beef wasn't that the information was false or that the doctors recommending violating the law, but that they were disputing the authorities' guidance. But as YouTuber Matt Christiansen observes, the WHO has changed its own guidelines. Are they violating terms of service for disputing the WHO? And how did they change their minds--wasn't it through pushback, not deference?
This should worry some of us who dispute dietary guidelines--the same people who own YouTube own the platform I'm on here. I backed up my blog to my computer tonight.
Watch the video, posted on 23ABC News, and decide for yourself.
Comments