Skip to main content

Bone Broth? Do This Instead

Move over, juicers: there's a new elixir in town. Boil some bones for a day, along with vinegar to extract the nutrients, and voila--you have the latest health drink. Well, you have it if you're willing to spend a whole day cooking it or pay $8 for a little carton of it. After all, it's water that bones were boiled in.

Photo from https://www.pexels.com/photo/white-skull-table-decor-417049/

Hold on, says Dr. Davis. He reports that bone broth is high in lead, and the ideal amount of ingested lead is zero. There's also not that much nutrition in bone broth. Who'd have guessed?

Nutrients in bone broth. Note the vegetable ingredients, the source vitamins A and C. Click to enlarge. Source: https://fdc.nal.usda.gov/fdc-app.html#/food-details/551729/nutrients

When he said this at the last meetup, some members in the chat said, "What about organic bone broth?" Does it matter? Let's discuss.

Even if organic bone broth isn't infused with (much) lead, it's pretty much expensive water. Regular broth is a fraction of the cost, or practically free if you boil a chicken, beef tongue, ribs or other meat yourself. There's another product available known as food. Certain foods like chicken wings, beef tongue, heart and pork rinds contain collagen, which the bone broth is supposed to have. Chicken wings only take 40 minutes to cook; pork rinds can be had as fast as you can open the bag and stuff one in your mouth.

But let's say time and money are no object. Is there some unknown value in bone broth, something people always had until recently, some Chesterton's fence we tear down at our peril by not partaking in it? WebMD says, "People have been making bone broth since the beginning of humankind. Anthropologists think people drank liquid infused with bones and other animal parts as early as prehistoric times." But homo sapiens have been around ten times longer than pottery. How did they make bone broth before that? Besides, wouldn't hunting, gathering, or a dozen other things have been a better use of their resources than boiling bones? (Think gathering firewood, hauling water, and keeping the fire at the right level over several hours.) One archaeologist in the Science News article speculates that people might have been boiling bones to extract fat and marrow, but the article also says that they might have been boiling meat, starchy vegetables, or snails and clams--or they might have even been making alcohol. 

The Weston A. Price Foundation promotes bone broth. But the book written by its namesake, Nutrition and Degeneration, about the diets of primitive but healthy people around the world, refers to bone broth only once. The Swiss villagers Dr. Price studied made soup out of the "bones and scraps" of sheep once a week. Indians of the Canadian Rockies, on the other hand, cracked the bones to get at the marrow and "nutritive qualities." 

Bone broth is the new vegetable juice, only worse. At least vegetable juice (probably) doesn't have lead in it. If you want nutrients, collagen-rich foods are out there, they're cheaper, and they taste great. 

Comments

Jan said…
Love the clarity, Lori! Well said.

Popular posts from this blog

Dana Carpender's Podcast; Dr. Davis on YouTube; Labor Day Sales

Dana Carpender, who's written several recipe books and other works on low-carb, has a podcast and is still writing articles at carbsmart.com. She's a terrific writer and amateur researcher (otherwise known as reading , as Jimmy Dore jokes ). I use her book 500 Low-Carb Recipes all the time and I'm looking forward to hearing more from her. I've embedded her podcast on my blog (click on the three lines at the top right if you don't see it, or go to Spotify or other podcast source if you're getting this by email). Carbsmart.com doesn't seem to have a blog feed, so if you want to see the latest posts there, you can sign up for notifications at their site. Dr. Davis has been putting a lot more videos on YouTube, so I've added his channel to the lineup. Click on the three lines on my blog if you don't see it, or go to his channel here .  * * * * * Primal Kitchen is having a Labor Day sale-- 20% off everything. They sell high quality collagen powder, con...

Fasting blood sugar & insulin have crept up!

It's pretty bad when even conventional medicine thinks your blood sugar is high. I had lab tests done last week, as I do every year, and saw things were going in the wrong direction. Photo from Pixabay . Uh-oh.  Ideal blood sugar is about 70-90. Your blood sugar can be high because you're stressed or ill, but I felt OK. I can't blame it on cortisol, which was smack in the middle of the normal range. And my A1c, which reflects blood sugar over the past few months, shows that whatever is going on has been happening for a while. My insulin is more than double what it should be. Oddly, my triglycerides, which typically indicate carb consumption, were good.  I don't have an explanation for the triglycerides. I should have suspected something was wrong, though. I've felt very tired and a little sad for the past few months. Unlike many people with higher than ideal blood sugar and insulin, I had only gained about three pounds.  Regardless of my good weight and triglyceride...

Interview: The Microbiome's Effect on Almost Everything

Mark L. Cannon, DDS, MS joins Bret Weinstein of the Darkhorse Podcast for a discussion about the oral microbiome and its downstream effects on everything from acne to Alzheimer’s. Dr. Cannon is a pediatric dentist and professor of otolaryngology (ear, nose and throat medicine). It's an hour and 44 minutes, but well worth your time. Link here: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=fjkOgCXiMeE

Avoiding a Nightmare by Using Math

The answer lies in trigonometry. -Sherlock Holmes Don't worry if you never learned trigonometry--the answers here lie in arithmetic. Medical test results often come back positive or negative, as if the result were a certainty. Of course, there is the accuracy, but if the accuracy is 99% or so, what does that really mean? That you should get your affairs in order? Before you call your probate attorney, let's take an example from the book Calculated Risks by Gerd Gigerenzer. Let's say you're a 40-something year old woman with no symptoms of breast cancer. You have a positive mammogram. What are the odds you have breast cancer? Using some assumptions about test accuracy and rates of disease based on real data, the odds that you'd have breast cancer are one in eleven according to Gigerenzer. (If you were way off, don't feel bad--most of the physicians Gigerenzer tested were way off, too--and they had the data in front of them. Not that that's comforting in every...

Lousy Mood? It Could be the Food

Here's a funny AMV(1) on what it's like to be depressed, apathetic and overly sensitive. Note: explicit (but funny) lyrics in the video. Hearing this song brought a startling realization: I used to be emo, but with normal clothes. Sulking, sobbing and writing poetry were my hobbies. When I was a kid, my mother said that she wouldn't know what to do to punish me if I had done something wrong. And yet things got worse. Over a two-week period in 1996, my best friend moved away, I lost my job and broke up with my boyfriend. I lost my appetite and lived on a daily bagel, cream cheese and a Coke for the next few months. I had tried counseling, and didn't find it helpful; in fact, I found reviving painful memories was pointless. Not thinking about them, on the other hand, worked wonders. Later on, so did studying philosophy and learning to think through emotions instead of just riding through them. But what's blown away all the techniques is diet. Since I s...