Was there a Thanksgiving Bump?

Wholesome holiday or superspreader supper? Photo from Pixabay.

Doomers warned of a Thanksgiving bump in COVID cases. "A surge upon surge," warned Fauci; "assume that you were exposed and you became infected," advised Birx. Some states instituted restrictions: New Mexico issued a stay-at-home order; Washington state banned indoor restaurant service for a month; Michigan banned indoor dining service for three weeks. North Dakota and Iowa, meanwhile, finally told people to wear face coverings if they're out in public. South Dakota stayed its libertarian course.

What were the effects of these various orders, or lack of them? The US has seen increasing COVID deaths and hospitalizations over the past few weeks. Thanksgiving was Thursday, November 26; it's now three weeks later. Was it due to Thanksgiving gatherings? Charts below are from CovidTracking.com, accessed December 16.

Thanksgiving bump?

Well, it doesn't look like a bump, but a trend that started around October. The trend must be because of those do-little governors in places like Iowa and the Dakotas...right?

Iowa

North Dakota

South Dakota

Clearly, these states aren't contributing to the rise in hospitalizations, and North Dakota and Iowa show what might be a bump in deaths despite their recent mask orders. South Dakota, with no COVID restrictions for Thanksgiving, saw deaths level off.

Are things better where governors banned dining service or ordered citizens to stay at home?

Washington state: ban on indoor dining service for a month.

New Mexico: Stay-at-home order.

Michigan: Ban on indoor dining service for three weeks. (*Various bans have been widely resisted and unenforced in some areas.)

To be fair to Washington, Michigan and New Mexico, Oklahoma and Tennessee, which didn't order any particular Thanksgiving restrictions, have graphs that look very much like those states.

“Oklahomans should be with their loved ones over Thanksgiving.”

Republican Gov. Bill Lee said he has no plans to impose restrictions, though he would “encourage Tennesseans to think hard” about celebrating together.

As far as I can tell from looking at the most and least regulated states, Thanksgiving restrictions had no effect on death or hospitalization trends--unless it's that several places saw a decline in hospitalizations after Thanksgiving, though I don't know if it's causal or the normal course of the pandemic.

*****

Has being free of government restrictions been the best way to go? It's not clear. North and South Dakota, two of the least COVID-regulated states, have among the highest rates of excess deaths so far--but they're immediately followed by Michigan, whose governor has tried to impose strict regulations. Counties whose sheriffs refused to enforce the emergency orders (Leelanau, Benzie, Manistee and Mason) have seen 53 deaths out of the state's 12,074. Michigan's dashboard doesn't show deaths per capita by county, but does show Detroit City and a few surrounding counties (over 200 miles from those mentioned above) accounting for two-thirds of COVID deaths. Pennsylvania, where police ticketed a woman early this year simply for driving her car, is between freer Florida and Texas.

Excess deaths per million, 2/1/20 to present. Created with info from the CDC and US Census population numbers. Click to enlarge.

The doomers might make a case that lack of regulation has caused a high excess death rate in some places. But I don't see any sign that canceling Christmas is going to alter any trends.

Comments

Lori Miller said…

Looks like Dr. Birx didn't take her own advice to limit Thanksgiving to your immediate household. https://www.wishtv.com/news/coronavirus/birx-travels-family-visits-highlight-pandemic-safety-perils/

December 21, 2020

Cigna is Making Progress

Yesterday as I put my lunch in the refrigerator at work, I noticed a bunch of unfamiliar people in the break room. One of them, Pepe, started in: they were there for the health fair, they would check your cholesterol, the sugar in your blood, your height, your weight, and it would just take six minutes. A coworker asked him if he'd ever considered a career in sales. Just for blog fodder, I participated. They really were fast, and one even found me at my desk (in an office nearly half the size of a city block) after the tests were finished. My HDL cholesterol was 65--up from 42 from a year and a half ago, and up from 57, where it was last year when I'd been three months a low-carb diet . A level over 60 is considered good. I haven't taken any medication to make this happen. I went on a low-carb diet and eliminated wheat. I also take vitamin and mineral supplements in addition to a high-nutrient diet. What impressed me more, though, was that the nurse (and Cigna) said that bl...

Thanksgiving recipes for Pumpkin Pie & Cranberries--printable!

If you'd rather read a printed recipe than watch a video, here are my recent recipes for Better than Grandma's Pumpkin Pie and Probiotic Cranberry-Apple Relish. Hat tip to Dana Carpender, whose pumpkin pie recipe inspired this one. The cranberry-apple ferment is entirely my own creation. Pumpkin Pie--no grains, sugar or emulsifiers Crust 2 cups shelled raw pecans 1/4 teaspoon salt 1/4 teaspoon monk fruit powder* (or 3 tablespoons sugar substitute) 4 tablespoons butter, melted 2 tablespoons water Pumpkin Pie Filling 1 pie pumpkin 1-1/2 cups half and half (with no thickeners) 3 eggs 3-4 teaspoons monk fruit powder* (or 3/4 cup sugar substitute) 1/2 teaspoon salt 1 tablespoon pumpkin pie spice Preheat the oven to 350F. Stab the top of the pumpkin all the way through the flesh in a few places at the top. Place the pumpkin on a cookie sheet and bake for 1 hour. Let cool. While the pumpkin is baking, put the pecans in a food processor with the S blade and run until they are finely...

Fly with Reuteri

If you're planning to travel by plane and you want to keep enjoying the benefits of l. reuteri yogurt, you might have gotten sticker shock from the price of l. reuteri probiotics. MyReuteri * costs $46 to $83 for 30 capsules, depending on the CFUs (colony-forming units, or the number of viable microorganisms). If you're thinking about economizing by putting some yogurt in a sturdy container and taking it with you, you can do that. I'll break down the pros and cons and look at some alternatives. Photo from Unsplash . Cost Yogurt might be less expensive than probiotics, but it isn't free. A half-cup serving costs about 70¢ to make if you start with a previous batch. It contains about 90 billion CFUs if fermented for 36 hours. This is a lot less than $5.56 for two capsules of 50 billion CFU MyReuteri, but for a one-week vacation, you'd only save $34 by eating yogurt instead. (You can freeze any unused capsules for later.) Furthermore, the yogurt would have to go in ...

30-second Fix for a Cracked Stick Blender

Use Mighty Fixit (if you still have some from 2012) or Rescue Tape (which looks like a similar product) to fix a cracked stick blender. After I fixed the attachment, I washed it in the sink and the tape held up. I also wrapped a knife handle several years ago, and it's been through thousands of washings.

No Dairy BiotiQuest Ferment in Apples + Cranberries + Celery

Can you have too much l. reuteri or SIBO yogurt? Yes--more than 1/2 cup of yogurt a day can raise your insulin or, in some people, cause sinus congestion or an upset stomach. Luckily, there are other foods you can ferment. One of my favorites is apples, cranberries and celery fermented with BiotiQuest Ideal Immunity probiotics. This recipe is slightly different from the one I posted before--I've left out the brown sugar and maple syrup since the apples provide plenty of sugar. Here's my four-minute video showing how to make it: You can buy the seedling mat here: https://www.amazon.com/dp/B01IDQD32Y/ref=dp_iou_view_item?ie=UTF8&th=1

Pain, Pain, Go Away!

Search This Blog