Skip to main content

Body for Life: What Went Wrong, Part 1

Some readers may know that I was a Body for Life enthusiast for six years. At age 33, I had no workout program, was a little on the fleshy side, and yet I was constantly hungry. A friend showed me a book called Body for Life (BFL) by Bill Phillips, and I was so impressed by the before and after photos that I tried the program. The plan consisted of eating six servings each of carbohydrates and proteins and two servings of green vegetables per day, plus six short but hard workouts per week. (A serving is the size of your fist.) I did, indeed, go down two dress sizes quickly and build muscle while eating more on BFL.

Four years later, I had recovered from a sprained neck and back from a car wreck and resumed BFL in earnest. But it stopped working, and by late 2009, I had put on 20 pounds of fat despite following the diet as well as I had before and being diligent about workouts.

Why did the same program produce different results at different times? This is the question I’ll explore in this post.

Why I think BFL worked, and then stopped working for me
I believe BFL worked for me initially because I was eating sufficient protein and lifting weights. The insulin released due to carb intake was used in building muscle. (Some weightlifters inject insulin to bulk up; I never did nor does BFL even mention the practice.) I believe that BFL stopped working for me because I was no longer building much muscle (I was lifting the maximum that my joints, not my muscles, would take) and because I was releasing more and more insulin, which increases appetite and sends more nutrients to the fat cells.

How metabolism changes
A person’s metabolism can change with time. The perfect example is diabetes II, formerly known as adult onset diabetes. Over time, the pancreas can lose its ability to produce enough insulin to handle excess blood sugar. Carbohydrate intake increases blood sugar, and insulin is released to send it to certain cells instead of leaving it in the bloodstream, where it can cause damage. High carb intake leads to lots of insulin, which can lead to the cells becoming insulin resistant, so the pancreas has to produce more and more insulin. When the pancreas cannot produce enough insulin, blood sugar levels remain too high, a condition called diabetes II. And the “lots of insulin” part causes some people to gain fat, which is why diabetics are often overweight. (People with diabetes I cannot produce insulin at all; therefore, they cannot gain fat without insulin injections.) You cannot get diabetes without certain genes; there are diabetics on both sides of my family.

Phillips himself says much the same thing about metabolism on p. 48:

Insulin is what I call a “nutrient-transport hormone.” It shuttles amino acids and glucose (blood sugar), among other things, into cells. But, when you eat too many carbs over a long period of time, your body becomes “insulin resistant,” and you can develop adult-onset diabetes, which can lead to obesity, heart disease, and a whole lot of other health problems, including unstable energy levels and fatigue. Eating a high-carb diet can also stimulate the appetite and cause unfavorable and unpredictable mood swings (especially in the midafternoon). Moreover, whenever insulin levels are elevated, your body will not burn fat....The solution is to balance carbohydrate and protein intake.

Stimulated appetite, not burning fat, and according to some coworkers, unpredictable mood swings (or "being unhelpful") was exactly what happened to me. So how does it follow that the solution is to balance carbohydrate and protein? I'll address that in my next post.

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Celebrities Shilling for Big Soda

There's a push in Washington and ten states to ban soda (and other junk food) from SNAP, a program for low-income people to buy groceries. This seems like a no-brainer: the N in SNAP stands for nutrition, and soda doesn't have nutrients. It's liquid sugar, the last thing we need in a country full of diabetics. People can drink water for virtually nothing and save their SNAP money for actual food. Yet a number of posts from otherwise sensible accounts have opposed this.  Reporter Nick Sorter says that a company called Influenceable has been paying influencers to post these opinions. (Click on the link for the full thread.) 🚨🧵 EXPOSED: “INFLUENCEABLE” — The company cutting Big Checks to “influencers” on behalf of Big Soda Over the past 48 hours, several large supposedly MAGA-aligned “influencers” posted almost identical talking points fed to them, convincing you MAHA was out of line for not… pic.twitter.com/PpPwH9lHGe — Nick Sortor (@nicksortor) March 22, 2025 Sorter adds...

I lived under a boil water order--here's what happened

Last Thursday, the sidewalk by a step-cracked building lifted up off the ground when the water main under it  broke .  I turned on my faucet and got nothing. All the water was running down the streets a few miles away, waist deep in some places.  Water main break, March 27, 2025. Source: Indianapolis Fire Department .  A man who supervises the building at the corner of the recent water main break in East Indianapolis shared a video with me, capturing the scale of the situation. Coverage on @93wibc pic.twitter.com/mUEkc2P78C — Ryan Hedrick (@suretocover) March 27, 2025 Later that day, after fixing the main, the water company issued a boil-water advisory for the next two days. If you wanted to drink it, cook with it, or wash your dishes in it, it had to be boiled.  As usual, I had a sink full of dirty dishes. No problem, I thought--I'll boil water in my canner. But it takes a long time to bring so much water to boil, then it has to cool down enough to put your h...

Many yogurts lack bifidobacteria despite claims

Physician-researcher Sabine Hazan had 26 yogurts and kefirs tested and found only three had bifidobacteria, despite advertising claims. She further found 16 out of 17 probiotic capsules she tested had bifidobacteria. One yogurt even contained bacillus cereus, a toxin that can cause vomiting. Dr. Sabine Hazan Finds Only 3 of 26 Yogurts Contain Bifidobacteria, Despite Advertising Claims Dr. Sabine Hazan, a top physician-researcher, uncovered a startling truth about yogurt and kefir. After drinking a gallon of kefir daily to boost her bifidobacteria—key for gut… pic.twitter.com/QMHR1mQRs4 — Camus (@newstart_2024) April 4, 2025 A solution? Make your own yogurt. It takes five minutes' hands-on time and three ingredients. 

$17/pound chips! Real food is cheaper

 My latest video on YouTube: Real food is generally cheaper than junk food--the pictures prove it. I took these at Kroger and from their website in March 2025. Prices are either straight from the tags or calculated based on product weight.  Music: On We Go (ClipChamp)  First photo by AS Photography: https://www.pexels.com/photo/vegetables-stall-868110/

What Is Atkins, Anyway? A Definition and Pitfalls

Over the years, I've read some strange ideas about what the Atkins diet is: All meat A crash diet Not low-carb, high fat High protein An eating plan where you gorge yourself Wrong on all counts. A friend of mine was curious a few weeks ago about what it really was. I described it to her, and she can't stop raving about it now: Friend: What do you eat? Me: Meat, eggs, cheese, non-starchy vegetables, and fats like olive oil, mayonnaise, lard and butter. Friend: How much do you eat? Me: You eat until you're full. Friend: When do you eat? Me: Whenever you're hungry. You should also take some vitamins. There are more details, of course, but that's it in a nutshell. How does such a simple diet get so convoluted in people's minds? I blame fads in eating and thought. A trend now is to eat vegetables by the pound --no exaggeration. Dr. Atkins' Diet Revolution specifically says not to fill yourself with vegetables--that's a tactic of tradi...